The search for an escaped Arizona inmate and his alleged accomplice led authorities to northwest Arkansas for several hours Wednesday as they followed a tip that the pair was involved in an armed robbery there.
But by late afternoon, the manhunt was concentrated again in northwest Montana near the Canadian border as local officials in Arkansas were convinced that John McCluskey, 45, and Casslyn Welch, 44, were not involved in the armed robbery of a hair salon in Gentry on Wednesday morning.
Benton County Sheriff's Office spokesman Doug Gay said photographs and descriptions of the suspects give authorities in Gentry "no reason to believe these are those individuals."
Federal investigators would say only that there were "conflicting sightings" of McCluskey and Welch and that agents were continuing to follow the Arkansas lead as well as others. Still, the Arkansas tip - valid or not - did not detract from efforts to search for the couple near the Canadian border, an official with the U.S. Marshals Service said.
"It did not affect our operations anywhere at all," said Rich Tracy. "We simply expanded - we did not divert any resources."
News of the couple's alleged Arkansas sighting came hours after investigators released updated photos of McCluskey and Welch indicating the pair had changed their appearances, with Welch lightening her hair and McCluskey dying his hair dark and growing facial hair.
McCluskey, serving 15 years for attempted murder, broke out of a privately run prison near Kingman on July 30 with convicted murderers Daniel Renwick and Tracy Province.
Authorities believe Welch, a woman described as both McCluskey's fiancée and cousin, tossed cutting tools into the prison's yard and assisted the men with their escape.
Investigators have made four arrests so far.
Renwick, 36, was arrested two days after the escape in western Colorado after exchanging gunfire with police, who spotted him in the town of Rifle. He was charged Wednesday with three counts of attempted murder and will likely serve time in Colorado before returning to Arizona to finish his murder sentence, plus additional time for the escape.
Province, 42, was arrested Monday after a churchgoer spoke with him in a small Wyoming town and later recognized the fugitive when she saw his picture on TV.
McCluskey's mother and ex-wife were arrested in Arizona within the past few days, accused of helping the fugitives move through the state before fleeing Arizona.
McCluskey, Welch and Province were also named as the "sole suspects" in the slaying of a 61-year-old couple in New Mexico.
A rancher last Wednesday found the charred bodies of Gary and Linda Haas of Oklahoma in their burned camper. The couple's truck was discovered 100 miles away in Albuquerque that same afternoon. Investigators said earlier this week that forensic evidence linked McCluskey to the crime.
The Haas' killing kicked a nationwide manhunt into overdrive, and investigators expressed concerns this week that McCluskey and Welch would prefer to meet a violent end rather than peaceably surrender.
As such, all tips- even those that place the fugitive couple thousands of miles away from their presumed location- are investigated thoroughly, said Tracy of the Marshal's Service.
When cases receive the kind of national publicity networks have given to the manhunt, they generate more of what investigators consider "ghost leads."
The media coverage helped investigators capture Province in a small Wyoming town.
Tips have also come into the manhunt's command center placing the fugitives buying a car in Goodyear and robbing a hair salon in northwest Arkansas, which proved fruitless.
"We eventually follow up on every lead that we get. There is a process where we prioritize them, based on information that we've learned, based on information that's probable, possible," Tracy said. "Ultimately we prioritize them and investigate all of them."
The Arkansas tip resonated because Welch has family members in the area, though a sheriff's official in Arkansas said Welch's relative no longer lived there.
Agents from the U.S. Marshal's Office in Fort Smith, Ark., were immediately dispatched to the scene.
But even an hour after the armed robbery occurred, David Gonzales, U.S. marshal for Arizona, cautioned against jumping to conclusions.
"This is a lead that looks very good," Gonzales said Wednesday morning. "But keep in mind that every major crime that has occurred in the United States in the last 10 days has been attributed to them."
Read more: http://www.azcentral.com/news/articles/2010/08/11/20100811arizona-prison-escapees-change-canada-border11-ON.html#ixzz0wMXHPzxH
all i would like to say is "thank you" gov. brewer, DOC admin and all the other dil holes that are protecting this state...never having a back bone to think this would happen...THERES you answers you assES in govenment seat trying to privitized prisons...the little regard you all have to back up CO officers...you all must think it's a babysitting job? you no good govenor, you keep fucking up this state!! THIS OLD LADY can not keep messing this state up!! SHAME ON DOC FOR ALLOWING HARD CRIMINALS TO BE SENT TO LOW CUSTODY YARD!! YOU FUCK UPS!!!NOW THIS STATE IS REALLY IN THE HOLE!! THANK YOU!!!!!!!!!
The director of the Arizona Department of Corrections has blamed the escape on "human error" at the privately run facility. Let us define Human Error – Encarta says “a mistake made by a person rather than being caused by a poorly designed process or the malfunctioning of a machine such as a computer -Most of the accidents are attributable to human error. So we look at this escape and find: 1. Bad use of classification tools for murderers and violent offenders 2. Bad housing placement in a less than secure prison 3. Insufficient concern for gang suspected affiliations 4. Insufficient concern for being involved with the introduction of drugs into a prison 4. failure to transfer inmates to a detention unit after visitor is caught with drugs 5. failure to arrest visitor with drugs 6. failure to bar visitor from institutional grounds and allow her to continue visits 7. failure to spot visitor on prison grounds after visiting hours 8. failure to supervise inmates 9. failure to secure the perimeter and avoid cutters thrown over fence line 10. failure to heed alarm(s) 11. failure to secure exit doors to exterior 12. failure to conduct searches that would reveal activities 13. failure to train staff properly to supervise medium level inmates, 14. failure of management to be aware of security flaws 15. failure of ADC to supervise private prisons, 16. failure to notify DOC in a timely manner 17. failure to update mugshots so law enforcement had a good picture of escapees so they could warn the public 18 failure for the MTC to accept responsibility for innocent killing of two in NM during the escapee on the run 19 failure of the director of the DOC to accept responsibility for his agency to classify violent offenders when the classification book allows discretionary overrides 20. failure for the governor to accept her agency’s failure to supervise and oversee private prisons in Arizona. Yup this is definitely an act of a person or persons that cause caused this tragedy. This was a systemic breakdown of the worst kind. Public safety was completely ignored by everyone involved and the system is broken, not human error anymore is it?? The agency should do a NO CONFIDENCE VOTE for the Director as he his hell bent to disappoint us all by pushing more cuts and endangering both staff and the public with his idiotic ideas of saving money. Just my few cents on this.
The question for the day: Who in the Arizona Legislative body / Arizona Government has the courage to challenge Mr. Ryan and his team on this escape to glean the truth regarding the exact circumstances this "opportunity" was afforded by MTC staff as alleged. This question, not yet answered after sixteen days of smoke and mirrors still looms on the minds of our citizens who expect better accountability than this when three convicted killers escape and roam the continental USA. Come on now, who has the guts to ask the question? How did they get out and can you give me all the details today, not tomorrow. The report is done, the damage is excessive and the risks are high.. Arizona citizens expect more than this.
http://www.azcentral.com/video/586557793001
I think that the DOC chief's spot needs to be an elected position by the people of Arizona. The problem with the system, is that since Ryan is appointed, he's basically a yes man for the governor and her party. He is not accountable directly to the public, who's safety he is charged with protecting. I think the legislature is afraid to investigate DOC because they are afraid about what they are going to find. After all some of the responsibility falls on them too thanks to lax funding and oversight. Not to mention the cozy relationships they all have with private prison corporations.
I'd like to see a FEDERAL investigation into whats going on here. People who are not personally vested in the current system and administration. DOC should never be allowed to "investigate" itself, but that's exactly what is happening here.